October 1, 2023 8:22 PM
| # | Player | H/W | School | Year |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jeremiah Trotter | 6-0, 230 | Clemson | 3rd | |
| Barrett Carter | 6-1, 225 | Clemson | 3rd | |
| Cedric Gray | 6-1, 230 | North Carolina | 4th | |
| Junior Colson | 6-2, 235 | Michigan | 3rd | |
| Jaylon Ford | 6-2, 235 | Texas | 4th | |
| Smael Mondon | 6-2, 220 | Georgia | 3rd | |
| Tommy Eichenberg | 6-1, 240 | Ohio State | 5th | |
| Jumon Dumas-Johnson | 6-1, 245 | Georgia | 3rd | |
| Danny Stutsman | 6-3, 240 | Oklahoma | 3rd | |
| Omar Speights | 6-1, 235 | Oregon State | 5th | |
| Payton Wilson | 6-2, 245 | North Carolina State | 6th | |
| Michael Barrett | 6-0, 235 | Michigan | 6th | |
| Ben Bywater | 6-3, 235 | BYU | 6th* | |
| Curtis Jacobs | 6-1, 235 | Penn State | 4th | |
| Ty'ron Hopper | 6-2, 225 | Missouri | 5th | |
| Jason Henderson | 6-2, 225 | Old Dominion | 3rd | |
| Mason Cobb | 6-0, 230 | Southern California | 4th | |
| Steele Chambers | 6-1, 235 | Ohio State | 5th | |
| Jack Kiser | 6-1, 225 | Notre Dame | 5th | |
| DeShawn Pace | 6-1, 220 | Cincinnati | 4th | |
| Jackson Sirmon | 6-2, 245 | California | 6th | |
| Jacoby Windman | 6-1, 230 | Michigan State | 5th | |
| Stefon Thompson | 6-5, 250 | Syracuse | 4th | |
| Eric Gentry | 6-5, 205 | Southern California | 3rd | |
| Power Echols | 6-0, 225 | North Carolina | 3rd | |
| Nathaniel Watson | 6-2, 240 | Mississippi State | 6th | |
| Justin Flowe | 6-2, 220 | Arizona | 3rd | |
| Jett Johnson | 6-2, 230 | Mississippi State | 6th | |
| Jamoi Hodge | 6-2, 245 | TCU | 4th | |
| Aaron Beasley | 6-1, 225 | Tennessee | 5th | |
| Jestin Jacobs | 6-2, 235 | Oregon | 5th | |
| Andre White | 6-2, 235 | Georgia Tech | 5th | |
| Nick Jackson | 6-1, 235 | Iowa | 5th | |
| Cal Haladay | 6-1, 230 | Michigan State | 4th | |
| Jason Johnson | 6-2, 225 | Central Florida | 5th | |
| Luke Reimer | 6-1, 225 | Nebraska | 5th | |
| Trezman Marshall | 6-1, 235 | Alabama | 5th | |
| Chase Jones | 6-1, 230 | Wake Forest | 5th | |
| Maema Njongmeta | 6-0, 230 | Wisconsin | 5th | |
| Jackson Mitchell | 6-2, 235 | UConn | 5th | |
| Lee Kpogba | 6-1, 235 | West Virginia | 5th | |
| Kalen Deloach | 6-1, 220 | Florida State | 5th | |
| AJ Vongphachanh | 6-2, 230 | BYU | 5th | |
| Bubba Arslanian | 5-10, 225 | Akron | 5th | |
| Xander Mueller | 6-2, 235 | Northwestern | 4th | |
| Shaun Dolac | 6-1, 225 | Buffalo | 5th | |
| Dan Green | 6-3, 245 | Kansas State | 6th | |
| Matt Salopek | 6-1, 230 | Miami (OH) | 5th | |
| Levelle Bailey | 6-2, 220 | Fresno State | 5th | |
| Cole Pearce | 6-1, 225 | Ball State | 5th | |
| Austin Moore | 6-1, 220 | Kansas State | 5th | |
| Xavier Benson | 6-2, 225 | Oklahoma State | 6th |
